Diving save by Asheville's Hamner

A point-blank shot by Watauga’s Brelyn Sturgill is saved by Asheville goalkeeper Anna Hamner during second half action on May 5. Asheville won, 1-0, to advance to Round 3 of the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer playoffs.

ASHEVILLE — Brilliant plays by both teams’ goalkeepers and backline defenders for 79 minutes were overshadowed in the blink of an eye.

The outcome of a May 5 matchup pitting visiting Watauga against host Asheville came down to the last 56 seconds on the clock. The game seemingly was destined for overtime, but within that last minute, the ball squirted out of a frenzied melee in front of the Pioneers’ goal; the Cougars’ Olivia Agan alertly nudged it into the net for a 1-0 Asheville victory.

Katie Durham

Watauga’s freshman forward Katie Durham sizes up a shot attempt in the first half of the Pioneers’ 1-0 loss to Asheville in Round 2 of the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer Championship playoffs. Asheville scored with 56 seconds remaining in regular time to advance.

The home team breathed a sigh of relief with the Round 2 win. Asheville advances to play another day in the 2021 North Carolina High School Athletic Association’s 3A Girls Soccer Championship playoffs. The visiting Pioneers’ loss brings to a close their ‘Cinderella’


Lily Brown

Watauga’s Lily Brown (9) poaches an Asheville ball near midfield during the first half of the Pioneers 1-0 loss in Round 2 of the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer state playoffs.

Amid the knowing tears that their season together had just ended, there were also laughs and smiles in the huddle of Watauga players surrounding head coach Chris Tarnowski after the game. Arms draped around one another; they knew they had given it their best.

Brelyn Sturgill

Watauga’s Brelyn Sturgill (3, white) fights for position — and possession — against Asheville defender Chloe Travis (3, black) during the teams’ Round 2 match in the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer state playoffs. Asheville won, 1-0, with 56 seconds remaining in regulation.

Lucy Willis

Freshman midfielder Lucy Willis (24) passes the ball downfield during Watauga’s 1-0 loss to Asheville in Round 2 of the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer state playoffs.

“Only a few days ago there was a lot of uncertainty as to whether we would even get selected for the tournament with our third place Northwestern Conference finish in the regular season,” said Tarnowski. “Then we upset the No. 1 seed in Crest on Monday (May 3) to get here, and follow that up by taking this game into the 80th minute against a very good Asheville program. I am so proud of this Watauga team and this group of girls, more than any team I have coached before. They grew together over the course of the season and they fought hard to the very end. Asheville won, but I am not sure they were ready for what they faced today in how our girls competed for every possession.”

Shaelyn Sheaff

Watauga senior midfielder Shaelyn Sheaff makes an acrobatic play to use her head to disrupt Asheville possession during first half play, May 5. Asheville won in the final minute to advance to Round 3 of the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer state playoffs.

For most of the game, momentum and possession seemed to favor the Pioneers. Asheville’s Agan had a good shot opportunity sail wide of the net in the opening minutes of the contest, but otherwise Watauga’s defenders and midfielders seemed to be ever present in smothering Cougar attacks, poaching balls and turning the action back upfield.

Maya Nelson

Watauga’s Maya Nelson, left, gets in the middle of an Asheville possession in the first half of Round 2 of the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer state playoffs. Asheville won, 1-0, with a goal in the final minute of regulation play.

Credit Asheville goalkeeper Anna Hamner for a few impressive saves on pointblank rockets aimed at the net from the feet of Watauga’s Brelyn Sturgill, Katie Durham and Shaelyn Sheaff. The statuesque, 5-foot-9 senior goalie dove and reached this way and that to defend against the Pioneers’ onslaught of second half shots.

“A lot of the first half seemed to be played in the middle of the field, trading possessions, while in the second half there was a lot of activity at both ends,” observed Asheville head coach Mike Flowe after the proverbial dust had settled. “This one really looked like it was going into overtime. It was just a very good game between two evenly matched contenders.”

Flowe also expressed some relief that the game didn’t go into OT.

“After winning in a double overtime match on Monday, I think my girls’ legs were beginning to tire,” said Flowe. “Those Watauga girls outplayed their No. 16 seed.”

Katie Durham

Watauga’s Katie Durham dribbles the ball during the left sideline in the second half of the May 5, Round 2 game against Asheville in the NCHSAA 3A Girls Soccer state championship tournament. Asheville won, 1-0.

Watauga finishes the season at 10-5 overall, 9-4 in Northwestern Conference play. The No. 5 seeded Asheville (14-2 overall, 12-2 in the Western Mountain 3A Conference) advances to Round 3 where the Cougars will face WMAC rival A.C. Reynolds (14-2, 12-2). The Cougars split their regular season series with Reynolds. Their early season, 2-1 loss on March 22 required two overtimes. Asheville then defeated the Rockets on April 19, 1-0, before losing 1-0 to T. C. Roberson the next week, on April 22. Ironically, Reynolds’ second season defeat was also at the hands of Roberson, 3-0 on March 28.

A.C. Reynolds advanced to Round 3 with a convincing, 6-1 win over St. Stephens.

The full Round 2 results for North Carolina 3A playoffs:

West Bracket

  • No. 5 Asheville 1, No. 16 Watauga 0
  • No. 4 A C Reynolds 6, No. 12 St. Stephens 1
  • No. 14 T C Roberson vs. No. 6 Cox Mill – not yet reported
  • No. 7 Charlotte Catholic 2, No. 15 Marvin Ridge 1

East Bracket

  • No. 8 Northern Guilford 3, No. 16 Clayton 0
  • No. 4 Union Pines 5, No. 12 Eastern Alamance 2
  • No. 11 East Chapel Hill 3, No. 3 Southern Alamance 2
  • No. 2 Chapel Hill 5, No. 7 Cleveland 0

Recommended for you

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.