Hodges and the heat map

Watauga County elections board member Jane Ann Hodges shows a heat map of population density in Watauga County during a meeting on Wednesday, July 18.

BOONE — A lawsuit over alleged comments during a Watauga County Board of Elections meeting in April has been filed by a former election poll worker.

According to the complaint filed on Sept. 21, Melanie Byrd Hollar claims that then-elections board Chair Jane Ann Hodges, a Democrat, spoke during an April meeting of the board against her re-appointment.

“(Hodges) stated to other board members and staff that she did not feel comfortable with (Hollar) working the election because that judge and her (now-deceased) mother used to plant drugs on people and that (Hodges) was worried if (Hollar) was allowed to work at the polls that (Hollar) would plant drugs in people’s cars while they were voting,” the lawsuit claims.

A search of North Carolina criminal records did not reveal any past charges against Hollar other than traffic violations.

Hollar’s attorney, Nathan Miller, said, “According to the board member I interviewed it was said in an open meeting,” and added, “The statement of course didn’t make the minutes.”

Hodges declined to comment on the case.

Hodges is the former director of the Watauga County Board of Elections office, retiring in 2015 after 30 years. Hodges was appointed as a Democratic member of the board on March 26, with Hodges serving as chair of the board until July; she now serves as vice chair. Current state law mandates yearly changes to county election board chairs on a partisan basis.

The suit alleges that as a result of Hodges’ statements, the board refused to hire Hollar for the 2018 primary election, and she was subsequently informed of the decision on April 10, one day before election training started. Subsequently, Hollar claims she was informed of the alleged comments in late August or early September.

Hollar claims losses of $2,160 by not being able to work the primary early-voting period and because she had rearranged her normal work schedule as a nurse to accommodate the workload. The plaintiff asks for damages in excess of $25,000 for slander per se and slander per quod, plus “reasonable attorney’s fees.”

“We filed it because Melanie was very hurt by the allegations, and they’re false allegations,” Miller said. “It’s outrageous that someone in a position of power would do this.”

Miller is also vice chairman of the Watauga County Republican Party and a past nominee for the Watauga County elections board, most recently in 2016.

Hodges and her lawyer Sean Perrin of Womble Bond Dickinson of Charlotte — whose firm has represented Watauga County in previous legal matters — filed a motion to dismiss the suit for “lack of personal jurisdiction and failure to state a claim which can be granted, on the basis of sovereign immunity.”

The motion to dismiss will be brought before a Watauga County judge on Nov. 5 at 10 a.m.

Perrin said he wouldn’t comment on the case until after the court rules on the motion to dismiss.

On Oct. 23, Miller also filed requests for depositions from Watauga County Board of Elections Executive Director Matthew Snyder, employee Donna Houck and board secretary Eric Eller.


(7) comments

Pam Williamson

Huh? If Ms. Hollar was never hired for the job in the first place, how does she have a claim for loss of wages?


Let's assume that's true Billy. How has she been hurt? How much money has she lost? How can she quantify her damages? She has to prove a dollar amount. If she can't, then it's a political publicity stunt

Billy Norris

If this had been a Democrat that was slandered, it would have been on CNN by 5pm. Melanie’s damages are listed. Its all cut and dried. Witnesses, slanderous words, especially about a Watauga County citizen who tried to help her neighbors, not plant drugs, and who suffered from cancer. Abominable! Hodges shouldn’t have the position on the board of elections.

Billy Norris

There are witnesses who heard Ms. Hodges say these things against Melanie and her deceased mother. Further, she had no proof. If any of you had been in recent meetings with this board, tou would have witnessed how Ms. Hodges acts. It is not becoming of an election official nor as a citizen of this great county.

Nathan Miller is only helping Melanie and her family get recompense.


Miller is getting desperate for clients, so he has to create controversy where there is none. This is what is wrong with our legal system, and our politics today.


And funny 😄


This article is sad and ridiculous.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.