BOONE — In unofficial election results, Democrats swept all three Watauga County Commission races in the 2020 election, meaning Democrats will occupy all five seats on the board.

According to the Watauga County Board of Elections office, 260 provisional ballots were cast that have yet to be counted. Provisional ballots are provided to voters when their registration cannot immediately be verified. If they are verified as being eligible to vote in the county, their ballots will be counted at the canvass on Nov. 13, when results become official.

There could still be mail-in absentee ballots to be counted, as the unofficial vote totals as of Nov. 10 included ballots received through 5 p.m. on Friday, Nov. 6. According to the State Board of Elections, 93,000 mail-in absentee ballots were still outstanding statewide as of Nov. 10.

Absentee ballots that were mailed will be received through Nov. 12 and counted as long as they were postmarked by Election Day. Watauga County Elections Director Matthew Snyder said that the elections office has received “a handful” of mail-in absentee ballots since Election Day, but that the pace has been slowing.

First-time candidate Carrington Pertalion won the District 1 seat by a vote of 15,933 to Republican Todd Castle’s 14,500, according to unofficial results as of Nov. 10. Charlie Wallin won re-election to District 5 with 16,214 votes, defeating Republican Bart Keller, who garnered 14,137 votes. John Welch, the current chair, was unopposed in District 2, with 20,615 filling in his bubble on the Watauga County ballot.

Welch and Wallin win four-year terms on the board, while Pertalion earns a two-year term with the third-highest number of votes.

Pertalion said she was very excited about the community supporting her at the polls, and was looking forward to serving the community while representing the entire county. Pertalion is also proud to serve as the sole woman on the board — the first since Mary Moretz served in the mid-2000s.

“I’m hopeful for the future that there will be more than one woman on the board,” Pertalion said.

Castle congratulated Pertalion, and said she’s “a fine person.” He said the two treated each other with dignity and respect.

He added that he thought that Republicans in Watauga can’t seem to “get over the hurdle” of voters from Appalachian State University. He said that local Republicans had noticed that people in their political party voted for the president and N.C. governor races, but didn’t finish the ballots for the local races.

“We preached that from the get-go to everybody to complete their ballot front to back, top to bottom,” Castle said. “There were votes cast that me and (commissioner candidate) Bart Keller did not get because people didn’t go finish their ballots.”

Castle thanked the voters who supported him, and said while it’s too early for him to say with certainty, he didn’t think he would run again for an election.

Wallin — who was elected to a two-year term in 2018 — said he was happy with the results so far, and that the votes indicate that the community thought he did a good enough job to award him a four-year term. Wallin said he decided to run again as there was more work to be done on issues such as public school capital projects, local ambulance bases and improvements to the county landfill.

“It’s exciting to be able to continue doing what I love to do,” Wallin said.

Keller was not immediately available for comment.

Leading the votes for the Watauga Board of Education candidates was Steve Combs with 15,006. In second with 14,970 votes was Jason Cornett, followed by Marshall Ashcraft with 14,006 and Ronny Holste at 13,725.

Combs has served a total of 14 years on the board with one two-year term and three four-year terms. As the top vote-getter, Combs will enter into a fourth four-year term. Combs said he continues to run for the board because he cares about the children in the county and serving as a voice for them.

To the voters, Combs said, “Thank you. I really appreciate the confidence you have in me, and I won’t let you down.”

Cornett completed a four-year term on the board from 2014-18, but was not re-elected to the board after running for a seat in the 2018 election. He said he decided to try running again because he “didn’t feel like (his) work was finished last go ‘round.”

“I love our school system; I love our county and I felt led to do it,” Cornett said. “That’s the burden I had on my heart for the county to serve at this level again.”

Cornett said he’s excited to have the second highest number of votes and that it’s been a “whirlwind of emotions.” He added that he’s going to stay positive and humble until results are finalized.

Speaking Wednesday, Ashcraft said, “I am grateful for the support I received and look forward to working with my colleagues on the board of education and with the leadership team and other personnel of the Watauga County Schools. I am committed to doing all that I can to ensure that we maintain and further strengthen this excellent public school system.”

In a Facebook post, Holste said, “I would like to thank everyone who had faith in me to sit on the Watauga County School Board. Unfortunately, it is not in the cards for 2020. Instead, I fell short by 265 votes. I would like to thank each new board member for their service for Watauga County Schools and families. You all have my full support as we move forward. Thanks to everyone.”

Ray Pickett, a Blowing Rock businessman and Republican who served on the Blowing Rock Town Council for four years, appears to have defeated N.C. House District 93 incumbent Ray Russell, a Democrat and owner of, by 2,757 votes in unofficial results as of Nov. 10. District 93 includes Watauga and Ashe counties.

Pickett’s win comes with a strong showing in Ashe County, which he carried by a margin of 5,729 votes. Russell, of Boone, carried Watauga County by a smaller margin of 2,972 votes, according to unofficial results from the N.C. State Board of Elections.

Reached on Election Night, Pickett said the results were still sinking in.

“It was a hard-fought race. It was close like we knew it would be,” Pickett said. “We really appreciate all those people who got out and folks who helped us.”

“We’re extremely proud to serve the folks in the 93rd District, all folks,” Pickett added. “I’m here to serve everybody and I’m extremely proud to do that.”

Pickett said he was disappointed that Republicans did not win county commissioner seats, but that he had faith in the commission to do what’s right for Watauga.

“I look forward to working with them at the state level and making the High Country the best place it can be,” Pickett said.

Russell did not immediately respond to a call and text seeking comment.

Republican Deanna Ballard of Blowing Rock handily won re-election to the N.C. Senate District 45 seat, with 71,445 votes. Challenger Jeanne Supin of Boone garnered 32,972 votes, according to unofficial results from the N.C. State Board of Elections.

Ballard did not immediately respond to a call and text seeking comment.

“While my loss is disappointing, I remain so humbled, inspired and grateful for all the work we have done together to make our communities more inclusive, compassionate, healthy and prosperous,” Supin said.

Supin said her campaign would be reaching out to Ballard to wish her the best.

“I am hopeful that Deanna Ballard will represent us in the way that our community needs,” she said.

“I’m excited about continuing to contribute in any way I can, particularly working with all the young people who really just bent over backwards to help me and help other candidates across the district,” Supin added.

In other races, Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper won in his race for re-election, defeating Republican Dan Forest. In a close race, Republican incumbent Thom Tillis edged challenger Cal Cunningham to win re-election to a second term in the U.S. Senate; Cunningham conceded the race on Nov. 10.

U.S. Rep. Virginia Foxx has secured another two-year term in Congress, defeating Democrat David Wilson Brown.

Recommended for you

(1) comment

eric stone

What a shameful mess the Democrats have made in Boone. The over development and traffic congestion is unbearable for the residents and visitors.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.